Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Editorial | Students need more answers about investigations into Muslim students

Published: Tuesday, February 21, 2012

Updated: Tuesday, February 21, 2012 22:02

During the weekend, The Associated Press reported the New York Police Department spied on many Muslim student associations at various universities, including Syracuse University.

Now that the original news has broken, more facts of the investigation need to come out. Why did the NYPD pick the schools they investigated? Why was Syracuse University chosen? Have the investigations ended? What were the outcomes of the investigation? Why was the NYPD allowed to investigate schools beyond their jurisdiction in Upstate New York or in Pennsylvania?

It appears none of the Muslim student associations were found to have done anything illegal during the investigation. The very fact that an investigation was done puts the Muslim students at SU in a troublesome position. These investigations reinforce a negative stereotype about Muslims that students at SU should not be subject to.

In a post-9/11 world, Muslims are often typecasts as terrorists. And while there have been instances of Muslim individuals trying to attack the United States, Muslims are not always the perpetrators and not all Muslims are perpetrators. The NYPD should be following up on potential threats, not just watching individual Muslim student associations.

Another troublesome aspect for students, Muslim or not, is that the university administration said it were completely unaware of the NYPD's actions. Students expect administrators to know what is happening on campus and to provide students with a basic level of protection. The university may be unaware of similar situations happening on campus that could affect the lives of many other students.

This news should concern students, who should demand answers to the endless questions that have since risen.  

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

13 comments

Anonymous
Sat Feb 25 2012 10:10
Rrrrrrrruff. Grrrrr ruff ruff.
CW
Fri Feb 24 2012 19:56
Problem for you is.... CW is correct!

Now, go back to your ACLU meeting and bark about your huge concern for civil-rights, and your lack of concern for common-sense, safety, and victim's-rights.

Anonymous
Fri Feb 24 2012 14:23
CW is "barking" again. Ignore him.
CW
Fri Feb 24 2012 11:56
Typical liberal / ACLU red-herring response! If the US gov't monitors Muslims or any person / group... we will soon be just like Nazi Germany, so it should not be done! What BS. There are clear protections in our laws and our Constitution that will prevent monitoring from going over-board. Protections that are NOT present in any of the home country's these barking civil-rights Muslims are from.
Anonymous
Thu Feb 23 2012 20:48
Reading most of these comments makes me sad. If these are current and former SU students, then I really don't know what to say. In any case, if you think that the government spying on its citizens is ok and that they should accept it since they got nothing to hide, then watch the movie called "The Lives of Others." It's a German movie (won the Oscar for best foreign movie a few years back), about the East (Communist) Germany's government spying on its citizens.
Anonymous
Thu Feb 23 2012 20:36
Wow, so many ignorant comments on this article. It makes me sad.
Yusuf
Wed Feb 22 2012 21:39
May Allah guide and protect us, ameen.
CW
Wed Feb 22 2012 19:15
These Muslims on US soil (along with their DO and ACLU advocates) are just idiots! They are so concerned about civil-rights! Yet, their home country would lock them up and torture them for blinking an eye.
CW
Wed Feb 22 2012 19:07
The answer I want? Why didn't the NYPD and other PD's start watching Muslim students soon after 9/11? We've had two Muslims in the Boston area alone that have recently been arrested, with trials coming soon on bomb and terrorist activity.
Proud-American
Wed Feb 22 2012 11:16
If it were another group that threatened Americans lives, perhaps the NYPD would be watching them too. If they have nothing to hide, why should any Muslim worry about being looked at and eliminated as a terrorist. BTW, owing a computer, smart phone, a credit card and holding down a job makes it easy for anyone to be watched and tracked. It is getting harder all the time to fly under any radar. Thank you NYPD and any other police or military organization for keeping me safe in my country and home. Keep up the good work!!!
Bruce S.
Wed Feb 22 2012 09:11
Okay, where would you expect to be more successful in the hunt for terrorists? Would you take limited resources and search among Muslim student organizations or among--well, whom? The innocent have nothing to fear in this case; the guilty wish to raise a smokescreen issue to divert attention from them, and the naive write editorials like these. "No man escapes when freedom fails/ The best men rot in filthy jails/ and those who cried 'Appease! Appease!'/ Are hanged by men they sought to please."
Anonymous
Wed Feb 22 2012 08:48
"In a post 9/11 world, Muslims are often typecasts (sic) as terrorists." Is that a deliberate attempt to be funny, or are you genuinely that out of touch with the real world?
Anonymous
Wed Feb 22 2012 08:20
The NYPD does not have to answer to you or anyone else. I am a resident of New York City and I am grateful to Ray Kelly and the NYPD for protecting us.






log out